Ideal acoustics for a studio is probably one of the most complicated subjects for any article covering acoustics. The reason for this is that there are so many different points to consider, such as:
- Room size and shape
- Need for sound isolation
- Dual purpose rooms requiring variable acoustics
- Personal preferences
- Budget constraints
And on and on it goes.
The simple fact of the matter is that it’s so in-depth that really no one, unless you have a super computer at the ready, is going to be able to predict EVERYTHING that is going to happen in your room acoustically. Fortunately, the real world is the best super computer simulator there is… because it’s the real world. What I’m saying is, the best way to find out what is going to happen is to just try it and see what happens. That can get expensive though, especially when things don’t do what you want them to do. This fact alone is what leads to what is known as “Analysis Paralysis”. People go out on the net and try to figure out what all they need and go to the nth degree trying to nail it all down on the first get go, and then find so many things and options to choose from that they no longer can differentiate between what is necessary and what is fluff.
On the other hand, I get a lot of calls from prospective customers who simply say, “I want a studio, how much?” Well that’s going too far in the opposite direction. It’s like saying, “I want a house, how much?” It could be 5 thousand, it could be 5 million. What all is the house going to have?
This subject really needs to be approached in steps – in layers, if you will, zeroing down into what is ideal for you. The first thing to ask is, “What am I really wanting to do with this space?” This is going to govern everything. If at all possible you want to have a room for live recording, and another separate room to do post production stuff in. These rooms will have vastly different acoustical attributes to consider – combining them always muddies the situation but can, to a point, be achieved successfully. For now I’m going to describe the two rooms separately, and then show a few tricks to combine them into one if needed.
Live Room. This is the room that has all the sound happening in it, from acoustical instruments, to vocalists, to whatever. Ideally you want to have this room as isolated from outside sound intrusions as possible. That in itself warrants an entire article which I typed up previously, see here: How to Soundproof (Sound Blocking). Treating the acoustics within the room primarily rests on the shape of the room itself. If you are building this from scratch, a great thing to do is to make sure none of the walls are offset 90 degrees from each other. Don’t tell this to a builder… things must be plumb! Not in this case. We want to minimize the ability for sound to bounce back and forth between opposing surfaces giving a flutter echo.
You ever have two mirrors aimed at each other and see and infinite reflection of yourself? It’s pretty cool, right? Not in acoustics it’s not. Walls reflect sound like mirrors reflect light. Offset your walls as much as possible. Another aspect is to make sure the length, width, and the height of the room are not all multiples of each other – that’s a great way to mess up the modes of the room, which is another huge discussion in itself. Suffice to say, don’t do it. If you are retrofitting a room, then you don’t need to re-engineer your walls, but you are either going to want to deaden them out completely, or make them diffusive.
Deadening out a Live Room. This is heresy to most studio people. While yes, it sounds atrocious to artists in there playing, we are in fact in living in the age of the computer and all kinds of high resolution effects can be added in post production to get back all the ‘liveness’ of the room you could ever want. Feed it through a filter and then pipe it back out to your artist in some cans (headphones). The benefit here is you get a truly clear track, it’s a clean slate to do what you will with it. It’s by far the easiest way to do this, and can be accomplished with 3” thick acoustical foam and thicker just covering the walls and ceiling 100%. Easy Peasy. To the right is a photo of a studio we did for the show Man Caves, where Sonex foam is completely covering the walls.
Making the Live Room diffusive. I’m not going to get too crazy with this. This is a huge subject of which some pretty good books have been written. The one I always recommend if you are so inclined is “The Master Handbook of Acoustics”, by F. Alton Everest and Ken Pohlman. Highly informative about everything to do with acoustics, and so in-depth in the discussion of diffusive environments, frankly I haven’t been able to finish it yet. The short version is this: Get diffusers. Diffusers cost generally twice as much per square foot as absorptive panels. But, absorptive panels make the room sound deader, where diffusers make the room sound better. That’s really the only way to describe it. Large diffusers like Pyramid and Barrel diffusers aren’t that great for small rooms, they are more for large band rooms. Studios should be looking for more “resolution” in their diffusers, or many small facets in each diffuser. The more of them you get, the better the room sounds. That’s pretty much the long and short of it.
There is a way to use absorption to achieve diffusion, though. If you could see sound, it would look like a partial bubble expanding out from a speaker, then running into a wall, and reflecting off looking just like it did coming in, still expanding in 3D space like it was before. Now, if you placed a striped pattern, or checkerboard pattern of absorption on your wall with even reveals of bare drywall between them, what happens is the bubble from the speaker gets broken up, each one of the reveals begins its own new bubble of sound. Remember, the more diffusion you add, the better the room sounds, so it stands to reason if you are on a budget that this is the plan you want to take. You don’t have to cover the walls 100%, you are using the cheaper of the two materials between diffusers and absorption, but you are turning your entire wall surface into a diffuser. It’s the best of both worlds. The illustration to the right shows what happens to sound from a speaker when it runs into a wall with a ‘scatter block’ pattern made with absorptive panels.
Production / Recording room. This is the room you will be listening to the music in, and you need to hear what it’s going to sound like in any given room and through a real set of speakers. Diffusion is the word of the day here. Diffusion on the rear wall behind the seated technician, potentially diffusion on the ceiling above the seated position as well. Then absorption around the console, here is where you just have to try it and see what you get. I recommend any flat surface greater than 6” x 6” gets 2” to 3” thick foam on it, but the easiest thing to do is to just have a knife and some extra foam sitting under your desk and just play with it as time goes by. The photo on the left shows a home studio we did in Michigan. Note there are diffusers above the seat, and absorptive wood framed panels around the console.
Bass Traps. These stop a warbling sound in your bass tracks which come from large sound waves being reflected at each other at 90 degree angles where walls meet other walls and ceilings. Just off the bat, get some bass traps for each of the tri-corners. These are the spots where two walls meet up at the ceiling. If you need more bass traps coming down the walls then you can get those later.
Many people will need to combine these rooms together into the same room, which is fine, but there will be a slight compromise in the quality of both rooms. The ideal way to achieve this is to have Contour AlphaDiffusers in the room, and as many as you can afford. They are probably some of the cheapest, and yet best acoustical diffusers on the market today. Specifically the Contour design. Most acoustical instruments will sound very alive in a room treated with these and produce a great track, as well as put the artist at ease while they are playing. For vocals though, you will want a dedicated voice over booth in a corner somewhere. You can purchase one made by ClearSonic and distributed by Acoustical Solutions, Inc. Or you can build one with studs and sheet rock, the key though is to make it as dead as possible. 360 degree absorption all around the vocalist in a 2” to 3” thick foam.
Ok, so hopefully this article has put things in perspective a little bit. True there is a lot left open ended here, but my desire was to establish a sense of pragmatism in the minds of those researching ways to treat a room for studio acoustics. It’s like a lot of things, it’s as difficult or as easy as you want to make it. If you have any specific questions or concerns, feel free to contact me at the information below and I’ll either have the answer or will find it for you. Good luck everybody!